This is Nikki responding (she knows about this junk).............
Hi there.
I have worked for a board certified veterinary surgeon for about 8-yrs and have seen a lot of fractured tibias on dogs. I have never heard of 100% guarantee with any surgical fracture repair, but 80% is an extremely high success rate. I can't think of one dog that wasn't running and jumping and walking normally after the surgery recovery period was over. Broken bones are not something that our surgeon usually even offers euthanasia for because they are something that can be repaired or amputated and not life threatening typically. Bones take about 8-weeks to mend so you do have to keep your dog from running, jumping, most likely keep an E-collar on your dog so that it doesn't chew on the splint, and you do have to go in to get the splint changed every 7-10 days. I have never seen our surgeon recommend using a permanent splint or "orthotic". Generally they are pointless, they rub ulcers in the skin, and the dog wants to chew it off. However, you may find different opinions from new school vets out there. It would be a huge advantage to your dog"s recovery if you limit the amount of food you are feeding and put her on a low calorie diet. Being confined and inactive can make it hard to keep the weight off and her body mass will play a big role in her recovery. I really do not believe a fracture this severe is going to heal without surgical repair and if you wait too long the bone will mend in the wrong position and will not be able to be repaired later on, not to mention it will most likely be more painful for your dog to endure the attempted recovery.
I am sure your surgeon also discussed the option for limb amputation. These surgeries are incredibly more difficult for the dog's owner to endure than it is for the dog as a patient. It only takes 2-weeks of rest and relaxation for the incision to heal and about a month until the dog is really back to herself. Plus, there is no bandage or splint change to worry about. Dogs are incredibly resilient creatures and typically bounce right back, especially if they are not very old. Also the front limbs on a dog is primarily where the dog holds her body weight so they do great with having just one leg on the back end. There is no lying around feeling sorry for themselves like humans do. They adjust rather quickly and move on with their life. If you were to choose that route keeping her thin will make it much easier for her to get around. I understand that is a big decision to make and not for everyone. It also isn't usually all that much cheaper than the surgical fracture repair.
Our surgeon's estimate for surgical repair with internal plate fixation would be approximately $3000 for the entire package. This would be for the initial consultation, surgery, anesthesia, lab work, hospital care, pain meds and tranquilizers, splint changes, and all rechecks needed for the recovery. Some vets will keep adding on all the extras and you don't realize that their $2500 estimate actually adds up to $4000. Most emergency vets and surgical specialists nation wide offer a medical payment plan called Care Credit. You can sign up online at
www.carecredit.com. Care Credit is provided by GE Money and you do have to pass a credit check. They send you a statement each month just like a credit card. What makes them different is they offer 12-months with no interest to pay off the balance, or you may choose a 48-month fixed APR of 13.9%. There is no extra fee to you as long as you make your monthly payments on time. We have used this plan at our hospital on a weekly basis and never had one complaint from a client. They have great customer service and have saved many dogs' lives for people that could not afford surgery otherwise. If your credit isn't great, they also have a co-applicant option. (Just another option for you).
Just remember, everyone has their own philosophy on how far you should go to save your pet's life or how much you should be willing to sacrifice financially, but when it comes down to it, it is between you and your dog. No one knows her like you do. Your old school buddy has a point when he thinks about how you could feed 1000 puppies in the shelter with the money you would spend on your dog's surgery. On the other hand you could also feed 1000 human orphan babies with the money that you would spend on rebuilding an engine. You can't try to save the entire world all at once, but you can do the best you can to take care of the ones that are closest to you. You should just make the decision that is right for you and your girl. It is a tough situation to be in, I know. I hope that I could offer some assistance. Let me know if you have any questions. I have to go feed some bacon to JR now. Take care.
Nikki