Wouldn't it be best not to mix brands on some parts?

-

harrisonm

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2005
Messages
5,763
Reaction score
8,060
Location
Topeka, KS
I am a pretty good mechanic. I have built several engines. I built the 340 in my 69 Barracuda up to about 375 HP about 20 years ago, and it still runs great. Here is my question. Sometimes I read here where someone has a cam/valve train problem. They say something like, "I have a Comp cam, Erson Lifters, RHS Lifters, Isky Pushrods, XYZ springs and Summit Roller Rockers" Ignore the brand names, my point is that there is a mix of brand name parts. I went with all Comp parts when I build my motor. I can see where you might think to select the best brand for each part, but wouldn't it be better to stick with one brand for a non race motor?
 
Yes and no, depends on the goal, as well as the pocket book.

Mixing a different valve spring, say a spring by PAC with a slightly stiffer rate can help extend the rpm of the engine. AKA, no valve float at *** rpm.

In keeping with all one brand, your guaranteed (or should be) a certain expected level of performance and parts that work together correctly.

Going with another manufacturer of, let’s use rocker arms. With a verity of different companies offering “There version” of a rocker arm, you would think there all identical in the critical areas. But this is not the case. In articles by AndyF, there are different lengths and widths and weights. This is where things can go bad or get real good. Few people put in the time and (big) money into investigating which part works right with there equipment and why others dont. Even at a pair of rockers from each company can be expensive. As well as time consuming.

This is where people end up with failing engines or valve trains etc....
It is a failure to recognize a ill fitting, aligning or operating malfunction. And it is super easy to miss. Sometimes you can see it so fast like a lifter. However mixing different brand lifters shouldn’t be an issue. But different rockers should be looked at closer.

Using different intake manifolds or exhaust manifolds/headers can yield different torque and HP curves. Going with an all Edelbrock system is a good idea. However, sometimes a different intake from Weiand can curve the way an engine works, accelerates or just simply drives.

Of course, there is also the spirt of experimentation and curiosity to help satisfy the mad scientist inside us.
 
Last edited:
Poof, it doesn't matter...
Scat rotating assembly, Crower Springs, Smith Brothers pushrods, Hughes rockers ect....
If it's done right, it's done right.
 
Poof, it doesn't matter...
Scat rotating assembly, Crower Springs, Smith Brothers pushrods, Hughes rockers ect....
If it's done right, it's done right.
Building it right is one thing.
But combo wise is another issue.
Hence the mixing of different manufacturers parts question.
 
A metal engine part doesn't know what brand is on the box it's shipped in.
As long as it specs out with dimensions and metallurgy is correct for the purpose it will do its job.
 
No.

Flat tappet lifters are made by only one or 2 manufacturers, the rest put their name on them/rebox.
Correct dimensions matters, the rest is inconsequential.
 
As a sidebar. If you have a failure, one manufacturer will probably fight with the other as to whose parts failed.
 
Good thing none of them warranty performance parts.
COMP Cams® warrants that all of the products are free from defects in material and workmanship, and against excessive wear for a period of twelve months from date of purchase. ... This warranty is valid on camshafts only where new lifters and proper valve springs are used, such as those found in COMP Cams® Kits.
COMP Cams® - Product Support Information

www.compcams.com/Pages/360/support-information.aspx
 
COMP Cams® warrants that all of the products are free from defects in material and workmanship, and against excessive wear for a period of twelve months from date of purchase. ... This warranty is valid on camshafts only where new lifters and proper valve springs are used, such as those found in COMP Cams® Kits.
COMP Cams® - Product Support Information

www.compcams.com/Pages/360/support-information.aspx
Funny is that's one company I would expect to have to offer a warranty... also one I dont know of anyone who would use.

Herbert,Schneider, Engle are my choice.
I have used lunati with decent results, but not my favorite.
 
Last edited:
COMP Cams® warrants that all of the products are free from defects in material and workmanship, and against excessive wear for a period of twelve months from date of purchase. ... This warranty is valid on camshafts only where new lifters and proper valve springs are used, such as those found in COMP Cams® Kits.
COMP Cams® - Product Support Information

www.compcams.com/Pages/360/support-information.aspx

They may warrant it in writing, but you will have a tough time getting them to actually exercise that warranty. They will do everything they can to deny it.
 
They may warrant it in writing, but you will have a tough time getting them to actually exercise that warranty. They will do everything they can to deny it.

Yep, especially when there is human involvement.

That human must have installed it wrong etc.
 
Never had any faith in comp parts. A friend of mine built a pontiac 400 motor. Put together with several go fast parts. Used comp cam cam and valvetrain. Cam went flat twice!! He thought some else was the problem nope comp was the issue. Replaced with a Crane grind as was well!!
 
I have yet to have an issue with Comp stuff. Only been using since 1987 though.
 
I've only had one Cam and it's been ground three times! Still hasn't went flat! But I think it's starting to get skinny! LOL
 
There also aren't many brands that make full parts "kits" for Mopar engines but far more companies that sell various individual parts or specialize in one area such as camshafts, pistons etc. Oftentimes those "specialist" brands are better when getting into higher-HP builds.
 
-
Back
Top