The only problem I see with the d rods other than reconditioning, is cycling. How many times have the originals been run up and down the rev range and "cycled" ? Ya sure they could magnaflux fine today, and in 6 months or a year from now develop a defect because of number of times they have been cycled. Granted new isnt always a guarantee either. But I'd venture a bet it's a better guarantee than older rods with Lord knows how many miles up and down the rev range on them. Better stronger materials used than what was common practice 50 years ago, better bolts, probably better quality control to be able to offer 500HP , and 6,000 RPM. I'd venture to say that's not the absolute limits for these parts, but rather a number assigned to them for reliability reasons.