If you do the xe268 cam and supporting modifications, you'll get extra power and the choppy idle you want. I get it, I love that idle on V8 cars, and it will come with a good cam so I wouldn't waste time on the thumpr.
You will definitely want a little gear, compression and stall is also nice. I haven't had a chance to really run mine due to trans issues after I swapped cam and heads, but I think it will put out good power for a 318.
Stock 318 block .030 over, stock flat tops, xe268 cam, 273 closed chamber heads (ported & cleanup milled) with comp 901 springs, mr gasket thin head gaskets, old Weiand intake, rebuilt factory converter with high stall (they said probably 2200ish), and just went from 2.94 sure grip to 3.55 truetrac. Doug's headers, 2.5" mandrel exhaust with thrush chambered mufflers.
[ame="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOTnCnB9ZoY"]Mopar 318 with Comp XE268 startup, rev, idle. - YouTube[/ame]