How about a cracked / broken oil pump? I myself have had trouble with pump / pan interference, and others have had troubles with ARP main cap bolts
I'm not referring, here, to pickup striking the pan, but rather the pump body hitting the rear of the pan
I usually run a high volume oil pump and have to use my trusty ball peen hammer to hammer on the pan so it fits over the oil pump correctly. I like to make the oil pan where it sits flat on the block without the gasket, then it will be fine with it. If you bang on the oil pan in the right places long enough, you can get it to fit.