Hydraulic roller Rhodes lifters in attempt to tame cam

-
Before I throw in the towel on this cam I’ll give the manifold vaccum advance idea a try and keep tuning on the carb

I don’t feel like over camned the car with the 112 lsa cam and a 239 lobe…. But I guess that’s very subjective

I have the older comp 274-Solid Flat Tappet cam. 236/242 @ 0.050 with 110 LSA.
And a M-1 single plane.

I have a “750” BG Silver Claw carb. It took some carb tuning. I have a tight converter. Float level and throttle plate to transfer slot exposure I have to pay attention to.

Did MRL give you an actual original cam card?

Do you have a dual plane?

This is mine idling. I think it’s a little better now.

Now it will idle in gear at 800 rpm. Out of gear it’s like 1,100 rpm. Might be off a little from memory, haven’t driven that car in 18 months or so.

 
Last edited:
Have a street 408 that I’m trying to make a little more tame and smooth at idle
4 speed 3:55
408 eddy head
239 243 hydraulic roller on a 112 lsa - mrl grind
Vacuum is about 12 at 1000 rpm
89 la roller block 10:1
Timing is 20 initial 32 all in

Hughes makes a fast bleed magnum style lifter, I was thinking of using them on the intake side only to knock the edge of at idle and allow me to set a 900

Any experience with this ?
Here we have an example of "cubes" not "eating" duration. Weird. All that aside....OP should be able to tune the carb for a couple more inches I would guess. J.Rob
 
So this feels like something else is at play, here is why I say so:

1) 408 W2 stroker here
2) Comp Cams 240/248 HR cam on 112 LSA as well (b/c I needed to worry less about the power brakes)
3) my timing is at 21 initial and 35 total, ported vacuum & fast advance curve

Motor idles at 850-900 RPM, pulls about 9-10", not great, but good enough.



I do have 7/64" throttle blade holes drilled to give it extra air, my air bleeds have been adjusted as well (Carter TQ 9800 series), and that allowed me to idle on idle circuit as opposed to transfer slots.

Are you sure you are on the idle circuit in your setup?
 
Have a street 408 that I’m trying to make a little more tame and smooth at idle
4 speed 3:55
408 eddy head
239 243 hydraulic roller on a 112 lsa - mrl grind
Vacuum is about 12 at 1000 rpm
89 la roller block 10:1
Timing is 20 initial 32 all in

Hughes makes a fast bleed magnum style lifter, I was thinking of using them on the intake side only to knock the edge of at idle and allow me to set a 900

Any experience with this ?

Just so you know;
The first cam in my 360HO, back in 2000 was a FTH, @292/292/108@.008 tappet, and
248@050
The Scr was 11.3 with alloy heads.
That cam ran mostly at +4, so, the Ica was ~70*, and she ran 1.6arms.
I ran this on 87E10@12 to 14 Idle-advance with the Orange box, an Accel square-top Super Coil, and a factory distributor, which I recurved as was necessary.
The induction was an ancient 750DP on an Airgap. Primary throttles drilled to sync the transfers. Yes on PowerBrakes.
I was able to tune this down to idle at under 800 unloaded, and to 550/600 in gear and pulling itself on flat, level, hard ground, by retarding the Idle-timing to 5*Advanced.
The car runs a manual trans, at the time with a 2.66 low, and with 3.55s.
Just so you know.
**
My guess is this;
Your cam is what?
284/288/112 and with an Ica of 69@ Plus4
With 20* idle timing, your transfers are too far closed, and your mixture screws are too far open, your bypass is too much, and I bet your secondaries are probably sucking air.
and, Ima thinking she's might be running cold? that's a guess, cuz too hot will run crappy too, but for a different reason.
IMHO, you just need a tune
and maybe a looser convertor, IDK.
**
Just so you know;
I got rid of that cam at the end of the first summer, cuz it didn't like 3.55s and that was all I wanted to run, cuz she was my DD.
What she didn't like about 3.55s was this;
1) I couldn't drive slow-enough. If I wasn't careful, she'd get jumpy down at 550, and
2) Top of First gear was over 60mph, and the 275s were still on fire after the shift. For a DD, she just had too much top-end power, and not enough torque down low, and
3) she ran hot all the time; which I later found out was NOT entirely the cam's fault.
Just so you know.
this combo was fine with 4.30s, except it was real hard on fuel, driving 30 minutes each way, to and from work every day.
**
Here's what I suggest; and it's just a suggestion;
Take the carb off.
>reset the T-slot exposure to a little taller than wide.
>reset the mixture screws to in the center of their adjustment range
>Close the secondaries up tight but Not sticking
Put the carb back on.
>Make sure the WET float level is correct and stable.
Set the Idle speed with Idle-timing.
> You must run a PCV system, and
> I had no problem running the VA on the sparkport, Mine ran about 8 inches at idle.
>For a streeter, I would get the coolant temp up to at
least 185; My car went 93 in the 660 at a steady 207
> Now I would fine tune the Idle-Air bypass. 7/64ths is what I ended up at, for pulling at 550 rpm in gear, but every engine is a lil different.
**
Here are a few things that you may need to know;
>The more idle-timing you give your engine, the more idle-power it's gunna make and so, the faster it's gunna want to run. It's just that simple.
>In my experience, cracking the secondaries for bypass-air, on a Non-4-corner carb, is an exercise in futility, two or more rear cylinders will run lean at idle, and then she got jumpy on me.
>Same will happen if you try to run a brake booster off just one of the runner. I rerouted mine to the Plenum. >The PCV MUST be run under the primaries, coupled to both bores.
>If your ring gaps are too tight, or your skirts are, it's gunna show up at idle, as an engine that labors to tick over; it needs more Idle-power. It may run easier when cold; that's yur first clue.
I first ran my Hypers at the KB recommended clearances; man I worked so hard on the tune that summer, you wouldn't believe. At the end of the summer, I swapped engines to my sweetheart 318 for the winter, and so, I tore that 367 down. I increased the skirt clearance and opened up the gaps on the compression rings. With a new, much smaller cam (276/286/110, 223@050) that engine had a whole new personality. I'm not talking about just Power and torque; She ran so sweetly, I increased the coolant temp, first to 185, then 195, then 207, which was magic.
> In my experience, I discovered that the Eddies liked heat. The following winter, at the freshening, I painted the heads, several coats of enamel in an effort to keep the heat in. and I slowed the pump down. I painted the AirGap too. I painted it all!
If you must know, "Hugger Orange" a Chevy color, lol.
> on the street, I can't tell the difference in power between 32 to 36 degrees advance. I mean any setting will roast BFG 295s so, she's usually down at 32/34 on 87E10.
> I bought and installed a dash-mounted, dial-back, timing module that has a range of 15 degrees. I set the timing with the device already advanced some, so I can retard it, on the fly. The range ended up for up to 6 advanced/9 retarded. So, from the front seat, I can retard the timing from 14 to 5, which totally kills idle power, or I can add up to 5* for fuel economy while cruising.
But there was a time that I used it just for fuel economy. I can tell you that there were times that my engine liked a ton of cruise-timing. Most of the time she is set to 56 degrees @2240 in overdrive, but there was this one time she liked more than 60.
If you use your VA for idle-timing as is so often suggested, what will your cruise timing end up at?
**
>BTW; You absolutely cannot give your engine the amount of idle-timing that it wants, and still drive the thing ....... because, the idle-rpm climbs out of sight. Prove me wrong. Go ahead, try 25, or 30, or 35, just keep throwing timing at it without resetting the throttle position, until the idle-rpm stops increasing. Now read your timing. What does yours like? 42 degrees? More?
Now put it in gear. Bam! Ok don't put it in gear again. Instead, idle it down with the speed screw. Now put it in gear. I bet it stalls. But if it doesn't, try to drive away. I bet it stalls,......... cuz the T-slot sync is way out to lunch.
The point is this; Since you cannot simultaneously give her what she wants, and still drive it, why should you care at all, what the Idle-timing is? Just set the sync , followed by the Timing-controlled Idle-speed to something slow enough but that doesn't cause a tip-in sag. If the engine labors down there, it most likely has other issues.
The first time the engine cares about power-timing, is at stall. Too much and she is likely to detonate. Too little and she gets lazy. You will not hardly be able to tell between perfect timing and up to three degrees not enough. But ONE degree too much and there is your piston-shattering detonation.
The point is this. Your street-driven engine is not a race engine, so don't let the internet bully you into trying to force your engine's timing. EVEN at WOT and at the power peak, that last degree might only be worth 7 stinking horsepower, and tell me how yur gonna feel that with a stroker at any street-legal speed; You can't hardly even run Second gear out to the Power peak with 3.55s; which will top out at 65 equals about 4400rpm.
Just saying, lol
End timing-opinion rant.
Happy HotRodding

PS
holes in the primary throttles do the same thing as changing idle bleeds. It's not rocket science. If your carb has screw-in bleeds, fine, use them. But if it doesn't, then the holes are, IMHO, a better option than cracking the secondaries. Theoretically, you could bring extra air in thru the PCV circuit, and I have at various times experimented with that. But, I am quite comfortable drilling my throttles. And yes, one time, as I was learning, I went too big. I just soldered the holes shut, moved over, and started again with smaller holes. How did I know that I had drilled too big?
Cuz the idle-speed went too high at my chosen T-slot sync. and Idle-timing. I didn't want to drill, but I had to know.
 
Last edited:
Dumb question, but if you want a tamer cam, why not just replace the cam? It'd probably be cheaper than a new set of roller lifters. Plus you could sell the current cam to offset some of the cost.
 

Said he gets kickback at 22. Maybe needs better battery cables.

Bordering on rowdy with the cam and definitely big for a "tame" build.
Better cables, better battery, better starter, and then (if your combo wants that much initial), a box with a programmable start retard.
 
I see it like this……..
It’s a manual trans…….doesn’t need to idle in gear.

Just turn the idle up to like 11-1200.
 
I see it like this……..
It’s a manual trans…….doesn’t need to idle in gear.

Just turn the idle up to like 11-1200.

Excellent point.

Mine in neutral or park is 1100 or so too.
 
Missed the 4 speed part. Leave it at 1K if the idle is good.

If it doesn't stink out the back at idle, drive it.
 
Get a higher stall converter Steel mounts and good sticky tires. Or just change the cam!

Here is a 686 solid roller. Engine sit smooth, No flop at idle. distributor locked a 34. 20 retard built into the ignition for start up. . I can never believe some members come on here with spark plug changes and all the other bullshit just to tame a cam.

 
I have the older comp 274-Solid Flat Tappet cam. 236/242 @ 0.050 with 110 LSA.
And a M-1 single plane.

I have a “750” BG Silver Claw carb. It took some carb tuning. I have a tight converter. Float level and throttle plate to transfer slot exposure I have to pay attention to.

Did MRL give you an actual original cam card?

Do you have a dual plane?

This is mine idling. I think it’s a little better now.

Now it will idle in gear at 800 rpm. Out of gear it’s like 1,100 rpm. Might be off a little from memory, haven’t driven that car in 18 months or so.


Never heard your junk runnin. Sounds great!
 
Get a higher stall converter Steel mounts and good sticky tires. Or just change the cam!

Here is a 686 solid roller. Engine sit smooth, No flop at idle. distributor locked a 34. 20 retard built into the ignition for start up. . I can never believe some members come on here with spark plug changes and all the other bullshit just to tame a cam.


Ya durn showoff. lol That thing sounded great! How are the plans for the reincarnation?
 
Not buying 248 @ 050 hyd cam on 108 LSA in a 360, idling at 550 rpm in gear, with 5* idle timing.
 
Ya durn showoff. lol That thing sounded great! How are the plans for the reincarnation?
My Daughter has Cancer which most of you know. I am helping her finish her car. super charged Mini Cooper S. She is possibly moving back home with her boys in July.

That car has priority right now. I have been selling things to help pay the co-pay for her medication and the parts for her car. Everyday I do something on it to help me cope with life in general. Just came up from the shop I was glass beading some of her parts, You can see my car in the spray room on the rotisserie in the back ground . That's where it will be for a little while. Just trying to keep her smiling.

100_0137.JPG


100_0138.JPG


100_0007 (2).JPG
 
My Daughter has Cancer which most of you know. I am helping her finish her car. super charged Mini Cooper S. She is possibly moving back home with her boys in July.

That car has priority right now. I have been selling things to help pay the co-pay for her medication and the parts for her car. Everyday I do something on it to help me cope with life in general. Just came up from the shop I was glass beading some of her parts, You can see my car in the spray room on the rotisserie in the back ground . That's where it will be for a little while. Just trying to keep her smiling.

View attachment 1716527357

View attachment 1716527358

View attachment 1716527361
That's gonna be a cool little car.
 
That cam doesn't seem that radical for a four inch stroke. I would mess around with the idle bypass air and see if you can get the idle to tame itself.

Pull your power brake booster hose off the carburetor and put a piece of tape over the hole. Poke a 1/16 hole in the tape and see if you can close the throttle blades down a little. You need to experiment a little with the hole diameter. 3/32 repeat the throttle adjustment, 1/8 ect. My bet is that your engine settles down a bit.

RRR is correct, your not over cam'd. The advance will crutch a poor idle circuit tune to a point... what converter do you have behind your combination?
 
Not buying 248 @ 050 hyd cam on 108 LSA in a 360, idling at 550 rpm in gear, with 5* idle timing.

but... but... he wrote a 1500 word dissertation about it and cited sources* how could this not be the right answer!?

*his own anecdotal evidence
 
Been stuck at work for a while. Thank you all for the comments. I’ll try to answer all here

Newly rewired car and starter with American auto wire kit

4 speed car, no concern of converter clunk

Lunati VHR18-VHR20 set to 112* LSA and installed on 108* ICL

239/243 @ .050" .367/.373" lobe lift

Engine doesn’t respond to more timing at idle. Rpm stays the same once I raise past 20 ish. Full mechanical in by 3000 at 32
degree. I use vacuum on ported for driving and transitions great from cruise to all out.

Rpm air gap
Edelbrock 800avs2 I previously had a quick fuel 780 4 corner carb that ate my lunch with stumbles and lean low rpm cruise. After several IFR changes I gave up. Car runs better than ever with this 800 avs2 out of the box. I’m really close and think this cam will be fine after some more tuning.

Idle screws 1 1/2 turns out is best setting. I just don’t like the sound of a 1000 plus idling engine… just picky I guess. The build of this motor and my goals have changed over the years as I have aged.

Pulling carb off tomorrow to confirm transfer slots and I will post the pics

PCV is a fram 191

IMG_2095.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Is it just me , or doesn`t the cam sound a tad small for this problem ???
I agree. Actually, the 112 LSA is a bit wide but nether here or there. Its size is a great street cam size for the cubes.

As mentioned earlier, check for vacuum leaks and ignition issues. Worst case, recheck cam install.
 
Seems you're on the right track I can't believe that cam is too big for your build especially with a four-speed. I have traditionally ran camshafts with duration of 250 at 50 on the street with a single plane manifold and idle at 800 RPMs in a 340 cubic inch motor. I also agree that going to a special lifter is not the answer but more of a Band-Aid.
 
If you have adjustable rocker arms, I would be tempted to try installing solid rollers on your hydraulic roller camshaft instead of the Rhodes lifters. I believe the lash needed for the solids may help tame the cam a bit.
Of course, after all the above sage tuning advice is vetted
 
If you have adjustable rocker arms, I would be tempted to try installing solid rollers on your hydraulic roller camshaft instead of the Rhodes lifters. I believe the lash needed for the solids may help tame the cam a bit.
Of course, after all the above sage tuning advice is vetted
If you put solid roller lifters on a hydraulic lobe profile you have to tight lash them because of the lack of clearance ramps. .004 or .006 lash isn’t going to change the aggressiveness of the cam in any appreciable way.
 
I have Hughes 1.5 rollers rockers
Preload at .075 1 1/2 turns
Melling jb225 lifters
 
-
Back
Top Bottom